Long-term Environmental Change

Geography 430/530:  Winter 2008
2:00-3:20 M/W, 201 Condon Hall

Instructor:  Prof. Dan Gavin, dgavin@uoregon.edu, 110 Condon Hall, 6-5787, office hours 1:30-3:30pm Tues.

Course overview:  Climate and the pattern of life on Earth has changed continuously for millions of years resulting in the landscapes we know today.  These records of past environmental changes have been assembled from a variety of different paleoenivronmental indicators.  This course focuses on the methods used for paleoenvironmental reconstruction, how Earth's climate has varied over a range of different timescales, how the biota, especially vegetation, has varied in concert with climate, and the theories that have emerged to explain those variations.  Emphasis will be placed on data synthesis and use of models to help understand the mechanisms underlying change in natural systems.  The field trip will occur towards the end of the course so you can apply in the field the material that we covered in class, and due to the greater probability of warmer and drier weather.

Prerequisites:  Geog. 321 (Climatology);  Geog. 322 (Geomorphology) or 323 (Biogeography).

Readings: The good news: there are no books to purchase in the bookstore.  All readings are either freely available online, are posted on the Blackboard website in PDF format, or are on reserve in the Science Library.  The bad news: to make the best use of the reading, you will need to print up all the files using a decent-quality laser printer.  One book that may be handy to own is Bradley's Paleoclimatology.  This is on reserve in the Science Library, but can also be purchased from Amazon for about $60 on the 'new and used' list.

Format and grading:  Lectures, a mid-term and final exam, and an annotated bibliography focusing on a particular method, theme, region, or timescale involved in environmental change research.  The exams will be given with open notebook.  Both exams and the annotated bibliography must be completed to receive a passing grade.  Final grade will be computed as: Exam 1: 25%, Exam 2: 30%; Bibliography: 35%; Class participation/attendance: 10%.  There will be two sets of questions posted on Blackboard for feedback regarding the readings, and for answering longer questions about the readings.  Academic dishonesty policies will be enforced.  (see:  http://studentlife.uoregon.edu/judicial/conduct/sai.htm). 

Course web page:  http://geography.uoregon.edu/gavin/courses/Geog430/


Date Lecture Topic (Follow links to outlines)
Jan 07 (M) 1
Overview of long-term environmental changes
Part I: Deep-time environmental change
Jan 09 (W) 2
Marine sediments: isotopic, geochemical, and biological indicators
Jan 14 (M) 3
Cenozoic climate change
Jan 16 (W) 4 Cenozoic biogeography: climate change and tectonics
Jan 21 (M)
Martin Luther King Holiday
Part II: Quaternary environmental change
Jan 23 (W) 5
Chronological methods; focus on radiocarbon
Answer questions on Blackboard: under "Assignments".
Complete by 9 AM / Jan 
24.
Jan 28 (M) 6
Late Quaternary ice core records
Jan 30 (W) 7 The ice-age mystery (Guest Lecture Pat Bartlein)
Feb 04 (M) 8
More indicators of past climate and biota: lake sediments, pollen, soils, middens
Feb 06 (W) 9
Late Quaternary ecological dynamics: rates of response
Feb 11 (M)
Exam 1
Feb 13 (W) 10
The migration paradox and phylogeography
Feb 18 (M) 11
Human-environment interactions
Part III: Holocene environmental change
Feb 20 (W) 12
Holocene environmental variations
Feb 25 (M) 13
Abrupt climate change: the Holocene record
Feb 27 (W) 14
Dendroclimatology I: tree-ring analysis
Mar 01 (Sat) Field trip: Coast Range (8:30-6:00)
Mar 03 (M) 15
Dendroclimatology II: paleoclimatology and hockey sticks
Mar 04 (Tu) optional Stephen Schneider lecture: 7:30 PM, 182 Lillis Hall.
Mar 05 (W) 16 Regional contrasts I: Northwest vs Northeast Holocene history
Mar 07 (F) Bibliography due
Mar 10 (M) 17
Regional contrasts II: Northwest vs Northeast recent environmental narratives
Second set of questions due.  Questions will be focusing on reading for lecture 16. 
Mar 12 (W) 18 Relevance of the past for the future (Guest lecture). [Lec18tn.pdf]
Mar 19 (W) Exam 2 (3:15)

Instructions for creating the annotated bibliography

An annotated bibliography (as used here) consists of a list of interrelated publications (usually journal articles) that address a particular theme, with short (3-5 sentence) annotations that describe a) what the article is about, b) its relationship to other publications on the same theme, and c) any other feature of the publication that would be worth mentioning.  Aim to describe about five publications (but this will entail looking at many more).


Example

Here’s part of an annotated bibliography that focuses on recent developments on the changing biogeography of forest tree species to climate change following deglaciation:


Title:  Post-glacial forest biogeography in North America
  • Prentice, I.C., Bartlein, P.J., and Webb III, T. 1991. Vegetation and climate change in eastern North America since the last glacial maximum. Ecology 72: 2038-2056.
This paper addresses the 'equilibrium' between climate and forest composition using infomation contained only in the pollen record.  Their approach was to use information in one set of species (taxa) to predict the abundance of another set of taxa.  They suggest that there has been no major disequilibria lasting more than 1000 years.
  • Clark, J.S., Fastie, C., Hurtt, G., Jackson, S.T., Johnson, C., King, G.A., Lewis, M., Lynch, J., Pacala, S., Prentice, C., Schupp, E.W., Webb, T., and Wyckoff, P. 1998. Reid's paradox of rapid plant migration - Dispersal theory and interpretation of paleoecological records. Bioscience 48: 13-24.
Clark reintroduces the paradox of rapid plant migration: the fossil record suggests much faster migration than seems possible based on seed dispersal distances.  Clark suggests that, statistically, one only needs to introduce the possibility of very-long-distance dispersal to account for these differences.
  • Shuman, B., Newby, P., Huang, Y.S., and Webb, T. 2004. Evidence for the close climatic control of New England vegetation history. Ecology 85(5): 1297-1310.
This paper addresses once again the issue of the vegetation-climate equilibrium, but their approach was to use newly available reconstructions of past climate using geochemical or other types of indicators of past climate that are independent of the vegetation record, and compare these indicators to the pollen record.  They note that each of the major vegetation transitions is marked by some kind of paleoclimate indicator, suggesting that climatic explanations are available for all of the post-glacial vegetation changes that have occurred in New England.
  • McLachlan, J.S., Clark, J.S., and Manos, P.S. 2005. Molecular indicators of tree migration capacity under rapid climate change. Ecology 86(8): 2088-2098.
McLachlan uses yet another new tool in the paleoecologist's tool box: phylogeography.  DNA indicators can reveal the relative isolation among populations, or in other words, how long populations have been genetically isolalted from one another.  McLachlan showed that northern populations of trees have been isolated for periods of time longer than pollen records indicate, suggesting very long periods of isolation and northern refugia during the glacial maximum.  This suggests tree populations may not have had to migrate long distances during climate change.
Etc...

Discussion

These studies show the evolution of thought regarding how plant populations responded to the large climatic changes of the past 14,000 years.  Concepts have changed following introduction of new and more sophisted methods: from statistical functions, to paleoclimatology, to phylogeography.  The trajectory of concepts is that from large ecological effects (post-glacial migration lags) to close climatic control of populations, and finally to the importance of small refugial populations.


Information sources

Journals:

The main journals that cover long-term environmental change or Quaternary environment topics include Science, Nature, and the following more specialized journals:  Quaternary Research; Quaternary Science Reviews; Palaeogeography, Paleoclimatology, Palaeoecology; Global and Planetary Change; Paleoceanography; Journal of Quaternary Sciences; Journal of Paleolimnology; The Holocene; Geophysical Research Letters; and Journal of Geophysical Research.

Indexes:

The principal indexes for searching for information on the topics addressed in this course is the ISI Web of Science.  This is freely available from computers on the University network.  Another resource is GeoBase (check under Geography in the Databases and Indexes section).  For major papers, you will be able to download the paper directly using the 'FindText' link on the search results.  Book chapters or entire books are occassionally important references in this field, and these will not be referenced using the above indices, but looking at the 'references cited' of a recent important paper may lead you to such books.


Last update:  1/06/2007
Department of Geography, University of Oregon, Eugene OR, 97403-1251
Course web pages originally developed by Pat Bartlein.
Contact:  dgavin@uoregon.edu