GEOG 4/517: Geographic Data Analysis
Nonparametric regression
Scatter-diagram smoothing involves drawing a smooth curve on a scatter diagram to summarize a relationship, in a fashion that makes few assumptions initially about the form or strength of the relationship. It is related to (and is a special case of) nonparametric regression, in which the objective is to represent the relationship between a response variable and one or more predictor variables, again in way that makes few assumptions about the form of the relationship. In other words, in contrast to "standard" linear regression analysis, no assumption is made that the relationship is represented by a straight line (although one could certainly think of a straight line as a special case of nonparametric regression).
Another way of looking at scatter diagram smoothing is as a way of depicting the "local" relationship between a response variable and a predictor variable over parts of their ranges, which may differ from a "global" relationship determined using the whole data set. (And again, the idea of "local" as opposed to "global" relationships has an obvious geographical analogy.)
Specific and general cases of smoothing and nonparametric regression
Examples of non-parametric regression
The various smoothers can be summarized as follows:
|
Smoother |
Form |
Influence of individual points |
|
|
|
|||
|
fewest assumptions |
loess |
no assumptions |
unusual points discounted |
|
smoothing spline |
smooth curve |
some discounting of unusual points |
|
|
robust, robust MM |
straight line |
unusual points discounted |
|
|
least squares (curvilinear) |
curve |
all points influential |
|
|
most assumptions |
least squares (linear) |
straight line |
all points influential |
Readings:
Kuhnert & Venebles (An Introduction...): p. 120-128; Cleveland (Visualizing Data.) Ch. 3